"To Feel Like a Woman Is Not to Be One" - Caribbean Bishops
- We must resist narratives that suggest the human person is a self-made project, detached from biological reality or moral order.
- The human body is not an accessory to identity.
- The confusion of our times - driven by ideologies that detach the body from identity, treat desire as destiny, and blur sexual difference - compels us to offer the light of the Gospel and the wisdom of Christian anthropology.
- The body is not a barrier to identity but a revelation of it. It is through our male or female embodiment that our unique personhood and our capacity for relationship are revealed.
- It is a scientific fact, not a social construct, that human beings are sexually dimorphic.
- Sex, then, is not arbitrarily 'assigned' at birth; it is determined at conception through the presence or absence of the SRY gene. If activated, the gene initiates the development of male gonads. If not, the gonads become ovaries. These biological processes demonstrate that the sex binary - male and female - is an objective, ordered, and essential dimension of the human person, forming the very basis for human reproduction and family life.
- When schools and institutions adopt gender ideology, they risk teaching children that truth is subjective, that feelings create reality, and that the body has no intrinsic meaning. This not only confuses but also endangers our youth, leading to increasing rates of anxiety, depression, and identity crises.
- Sex is not a spectrum. It is a binary reality, inscribed in our nature, affirmed by biology, and upheld by faith.
- A person may say, 'I feel like a woman' or 'I feel like a man,' but such feelings, however sincere, do not define reality. To feel like a woman is not to be one. Feelings are not facts.
- A man cannot know what it is to be a woman from the inside. His speculation is only from the outside, based on imagined traits. Such self-identification is a fiction, not a foundation for human identity.
- While the Church recognises the deep suffering involved, we cannot affirm mistaken self-perceptions. This would be akin to affirming the belief of one living with anorexia nervosa that they are overweight despite being underweight.
- Real compassion seeks to heal, not reinforce, a harmful disconnect between mind and body.
- Such interventions cannot change one's sex, and often result in permanent harm, including sterilisation, loss of sexual function, and psychological distress.
#newsDxbyiiuigs